Yes, this would be the method for sure. What I meant to point out is that Buckeyes are meant to be meat birds, not super layers. YOu might remember in conversations on the heritage thread that usually a breed needs to be one or the other; only a rare few can do both well = they are the exceptions. Jeff Lay is h ighly respected and has alway been gracious in hiss emails, so I value what is his choice/options. Perhaps it will attract others interested in the egg aspect to meet the buckeyes and then realize they are also a wonderful meat bird.
One of the reasons I picked the buckeye was because if I have 15 pullets/ hens, I can't eat a dozen eggs a day, and the cost of production is much higher to supply enough p rotein and nutrients to pack on the meat if a growing pullet and put out an egg a day. I eat a lot of eggs every day, but even I get sick of eggs, eggs, eggs.
I'm already overloaded with eggs, and it is time to start pickling and freezing . . . . for the lean fall/ winter.
In my case in particular I"m trying to find a bird that can match the rhythm of feed production at my own farm. Feed prices keep soaring: In the last 6 ish years my grain prices have doubled and hay has doubled. Constant threats of grain shortage gives me sleepless nights. Much of our grain is going abroad--- we are bleeding ourselves dry. WE produced it ,we keep it. I don't know the current numbers, but I'm betting there is still a high $$ amt spent on subsidizing the farming in the US. Called the Farm BIll. I only know enough to be scared. So . . . Looking to have the land be their primary food source. A big change from eating out of a bag. lol
Trap nesting has its place-- would really like to know how many eggs the old girls are giving-- they are producing but how many? THey are fat and sleek and glossy . . . production is certainly down. THese girls are my learning ground -- a trap nest system would be helpful to breed from productive old girls.
Dual purpose breeds like the Buckeye are supposed to be good at both. Yes, one breed or strain may have an emphasis to one side. That is not speaking of their potential though. You can certainly have both. That is the idea after all, and part of it. If I could trap nest, I would.
It sounds like you need to sell a few eggs. It helps with the feed bill. I do not hassle with selling a lot, but I share a few. It makes a difference. I have that problem to. I cannot eat all of the eggs a couple dozen hens produce. I was reluctant about selling eggs, and I still do not get into it. The few I share with people I know does help.
I tend to think that grain prices will end up being a problem myself. It has motivated me to re think why I keep poultry and what I keep. More and more I have grown fond of the lighter more active breeds. When I think of the word sustainable, I tend to think that means in leaner times as well. In leaner times, I do not see my big eaters making it. I see them ending up in a pot. I am speaking of a hypothetical scenario.
I have grown to be fond of birds that still put plenty of eggs on the counter, while rustling up much of their own food from the hedgerow. It hit me, the drastic difference, when these Catalanas were eating 25% less than my other birds, but were laying more eggs and larger eggs. This difference being if they were allowed to range freely. There is still a difference, but a smaller difference when confined. The Catalanas are clearly more adept at rustling up their own.
With access to affordable grain, even in leaner times (thinking in terms of sustainable), a good all round dual purpose bird still has it's role. More, if you are growing your own corn or wheat, for example. Buckeyes certainly can fit in that role. I like what Don has done with the breed, and what some others are doing now. I like the New Hampshire and Delaware for this role to. Concerning the potential anyways.
My NHs are not where I want them, but they have more potential than most that I have kept. In the last 20 years I have tried quite a few things, and I have what I want and like. One that I would like to try (that I have not) before my time is the good old fashioned, standard bred, Brown Leghorn.