A.T. Hagan :
I think everyone should use whatever brooder bedding that it pleases them to use. Your chicks, your brooder, your call.
But what I don't understand is why some of you are so resistant to the idea of using shavings when it sounds like from what you've posted above that you have never actually USED them before.
Use them or don't use them I don't care, but I can say that this fear of the birds eating the shavings and dying because of it is completely unfounded. I have 120 chicks on shavings in two brooders right this moment. All doing just fine. They scratch and peck through the shavings constantly because it is a chicken's nature to scratch and peck any time they are on a surface that allows them to do so. I've raised hundreds of chicks like this and untold millions have been raised on shavings for many decades now. So long as there is feed in the brooder and they know where it is they will eat the feed not the shavings.
Use whatever bedding you like. They are your birds. But some of you seem to have made up your mind about how bad shavings are without ever having actually tried them before.
I agree. I'm resistant (and I have never actually USED it before) because it LOOKS unsafe. I will not use something that I am not comfortable using. I have actually visited other chicken owners that use shavings and I have picked up the shavings and watched the chicks and it makes me cringe to see it. Frightening sight. I guess it's the same as the guinea who died with some type of thread inside of it (from a used towel). I, like you, have raised hundreds of baby chicks on towels and puppy pads for 10 years and have never lost one. Any my recycled towels and puppy pads are free. I can't get free shavings.
I have not paid a penny for bedding in 10 years.
Just a personal choice for every chicken owner. Sounds like shavings work for you. Way to go.