Broody hen doesn't like being blocked in

HollyDutton

Chirping
Apr 17, 2018
65
50
73
Houston, TX
So, background:
We have a flock of about 12 that lay roughly 8 a day or so. Two are broody (started week and a half ago). No roosters, so all eggs here are infertile. I decided to get some fertile eggs and picked one hen to be the setter (she would scoot eggs over under her, got major fluffed up and made "back off" sounds when approached... the other broody would just sit there hot in a stupor).

Added some alternate laying spots for the other girls (cat litter boxes) and blocked the chosen broody into the preferred nesting box with a wire dog pen, and food and water. Slid some purchased fertile eggs under her last night at 7pm and she stayed on them until first getting out today around 2pm. First time we've tried hatching anything.

She had been getting off the infertile eggs and returning to the box after a stretch/eat/poop/bath. Usually someone else would hop in there and lay, or else the other broody would be in there anyhow (often the 2 of them were in there at the same time, for hours on end, and overnight). Well, when she emerged this afternoon she was NOT happy to be blocked in. Rammed the wire cage enough that it jarred open a door, and she got out. Not sure she could figure out how to get back IN, my husband just slid the cage away from the box, for full unfettered access to it (for anyone).

After an hour she came back in and went back in the box with the fertile eggs. Are those eggs lost, by not having anyone on them for an hour, after being slid in last night?

We weren't experienced enough when setting up the coop to make the box easy to get to for anything but just picking up eggs - it's awkward and around a corner inside a door at waist height. The coop is not a walk-in coop.

So my question is... if this agitates her being blocked in, that doesn't seem like the best way to go, unless we just assume she'll get over it, and be OK with being confined to a 2'x3' dog cage outside her box, for 3 weeks. I don't want to see her hurt herself trying to get out again.

The other hens had used a couple of the alternate laying boxes, so if they continue to do that, that's good. Would it be OK to just let anyone in to either lay, or sit on the eggs, without collecting the infertile ones, unless we happen to be there when nobody is in the box (when we can easily see which eggs are which)?

And... would any infertile eggs that have been sat on in the next 3 weeks be ok to eat?

I don't want to handle the fertile eggs too much by having to pick all of the eggs up in order to determine which is which, on a daily basis. But if it's bad to leave infertile eggs in there, we'll either need to monitor on the camera for when there is no broody in there, and quickly remove the infertile eggs for the day, or else pull a broody out, which sounds disruptive.

Hope this makes sense!

Thanks.
 
The cage is slid up to the front of the box (only one opening into/out of the box) kinda like an extension of it. There's enough material in there, and she was pulling in some hay earlier in the day.
55882056_10104683264048445_8426589229022183424_n.jpg
 

Attachments

  • 22308670_10154595265626706_5286965603526935439_n.jpg
    22308670_10154595265626706_5286965603526935439_n.jpg
    102 KB · Views: 6
I wouldn't block a broody hen into a small area. They like to be able to get up, breathe, stretch, walk around, and dustbathe. Dustbathing is especially important because setting hens are vulnerable to mites. They also, understandably, wish to poop a ways away from their nests.

The two issues I see with leaving a broody hen in an area other hens can access are:
The other hens might accidentally smash one or two of the eggs she's setting
The other hens might fight with her to access the spot.

If you're not having issues with either of those two things, I would just leave her be. Mark the eggs she's setting with a pencil, collect the infertile eggs at least once a week (and they should be safe to eat.)

Also, in warm weather, an hour is not an unreasonable period for a broody to be away from the nest.
 
I have had several broody hens hatch in cages like that but I make a nest box and put it in the cage then set everything up including the eggs and go get the broody and put her in. As soon as they see the eggs there eyes glaze over and zoom onto the eggs. Only problem I have had is cleaning out the broody poop yuk. Your girl should settle in ok unless she is young and just not ready yet.
 
If you're not having issues with either of those two things, I would just leave her be. Mark the eggs she's setting with a pencil, collect the infertile eggs at least once a week (and they should be safe to eat.)

Also, in warm weather, an hour is not an unreasonable period for a broody to be away from the nest.

We haven’t had a broken egg yet, despite only having one nesting box until just recently.

That’s a relief about edibility and time off the eggs.

Thanks :)
 
I have had several broody hens hatch in cages like that but I make a nest box and put it in the cage then set everything up including the eggs and go get the broody and put her in. As soon as they see the eggs there eyes glaze over and zoom onto the eggs. Only problem I have had is cleaning out the broody poop yuk. Your girl should settle in ok unless she is young and just not ready yet.

She’s 9months and this is her first time being broody - it’s a new experience for all of us!

I was really surprised to see her strong reaction of wanting OUT of the dog crate.

Lemme see if I can figure out how to add a video...

DH has slid the cage back over the box now that she has returned, and secured it shut. I guess just see how she does next time?
 
Yeah, that crate is kind of a small space.
I have a 4x6 space in coop to separate broodies.
I put them in there with a floor nest and fake eggs until they settle down again.
They do not like being separated/confined,
but if really broody choose the nest and settle back in,
can take up to a full day.
Then I give them the fresh fertile eggs and mark the calendar.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom