the good the bad and the ugly
Well it's interesting hearing everyone else's experience of broody hens.
The good - I have a part silkie/EE/BCM hen who is not a year old yet but is broody for the 2nd time this year. She just finished raising 4 chantecler/EE little gangbusters
Anyway she is double bumming a nest with a turkey hen - who normally would peck her out of the way at feeding time. Strange bedfellows.... 7 turkey eggs and 1 bantam olive green egg under her/them.
Another good is that one of my broodies stopped mothering 3 chicks at about 4 weeks of age - 2 weeks later (they were warily integrating with the flock but not happy that their mama didn't want to know them anymore) one of the older hens has suddenly adopted them, and is happily taking them around everywhere and cuddling them at night. So sweet and unexpected - she has never gone broody for me before.
The ugly - I placed 5 3 day old chicks under a broody I had moved to a quiet dog crate a couple of days before. I did it at night and sat in the henhouse in the dark for an hour listening to her. one chick wandered out immediately, she pecked at it, and I grabbed that one and kept it and returned it eventually to my ecoglow. The other 4 seemed to be well settled under her, although she didn't make any noises to them and did occasionally peck at herself - her wing, and the side of the cage-. I waited and waited, the chicks all quieted and went to sleep and she seemed to settle well so after an hour I left.
In the morning I was horrified to find 2 dead chicks and a 3rd one pipping loudly at the front of the cage. She had pecked them all, and the 3rd one despite my intense efforts died 2 days later. One was still under her, sleeping quietly, and I scooped that one out and brought it back into the brooder.
Aside from feeling a complete failure as a chicken mother, I did wonder if I should have just put 1 under her the first night. Was she overwhelmed? In the past I have given 4 chicks to broodies in one go, and they were completely accepted.
Should I only ever leave them under if I hear the broody make clucking noises to the chicks? Because I have also had broodies who didn't talk the first night, but were excellent mothers.