I had a successful hatch with 1 of 2 of my broodies. The White Plymouth Rock was nearly perfect. Clean nest and hatched 10 out of 12 eggs--she exhibited broody behavior and I set her aside in a large dog pen and the next day she was still committed so I put 12 fertile Buckeye eggs under her. I only candled a couple of times and new the two that were duds ahead of time and removed them. She kept her nest very Clean--then I had an Australorp that went broody the same time and did the exact same things with her--except she did not keep her nest clean--and I think bacteria killed all of her eggs, I tried keeping the nest clean but it seemed futile. She also started eating her eggs I think because they started disappearing. She hatched no eggs. In fact as I removed the final eggs many of them were rotten--Here's a pic of the happy mama and her babies: Any ideas on what went wrong with the Australorp? The eggs should have been identical in quality and fertility--same bread and collected at the same time, etc. I am going to let her raise them--how long should the chicks stay with her? Thanks!!
