You may have a space issue. General ideal space is 4’x4’ per bird in the coop (not including nest boxes and storage) and 10’x10’ in the run.
You don’t give measurements for your coop but in my experience a prefab coop for 4-6 birds is really only big enough for 2.
Your original 4 birds were probably perfectly happy in their setup. And I’m not saying it’s a bad setup. What may have caused issue was the 2 new birds. If the 2 older birds were used to free ranging all day and a palatial coop they could very well be cranky.
I would definitely try removing the bully for a bit and trying to reset the pecking order. If that doesn’t work I’d try again and reintroduce with the pinless peepers. If a second attempt doesn’t fix the problem, unless you want to expand, rehoming may be the answer.
Good Luck!
I will say I took on a hen no one wanted because she was known to be bossy. I’ve not had a single problem with her. Sometimes it takes a change of scenery.
You don’t give measurements for your coop but in my experience a prefab coop for 4-6 birds is really only big enough for 2.
Your original 4 birds were probably perfectly happy in their setup. And I’m not saying it’s a bad setup. What may have caused issue was the 2 new birds. If the 2 older birds were used to free ranging all day and a palatial coop they could very well be cranky.
I would definitely try removing the bully for a bit and trying to reset the pecking order. If that doesn’t work I’d try again and reintroduce with the pinless peepers. If a second attempt doesn’t fix the problem, unless you want to expand, rehoming may be the answer.
Good Luck!
I will say I took on a hen no one wanted because she was known to be bossy. I’ve not had a single problem with her. Sometimes it takes a change of scenery.