Yes I Have Both.... Butlers= The Sumo Wrestler Of Bob Whites!!!
No Differences In Birds As Far As Personality---- A Bob Is A Bob Is A Bob.... They're All The Lil Junkyard Dogs Of The Quail World.... The Butlers Are Slightly Less Flighty As It Takes More Energy To Get That Amount Of Quail Off The Ground.... But Since They Dont Fly They're Content To Stay On The Ground And Put Up A Good Fight. As Far As Size---- (here's The Disclaimer--- "true") True Butlers Are Quite A Bit Larger Than Ga Giants--- By Like 50-70% Bigger. Butlers While Very Slow Growing, Will Get Close To Or Right At 32oz On The Big End--- Now It Takes A While To Do That, They Will Continue To Grow And Develope Additional Size For Up To 18 Mos. They End Up Somewhere's Near Bantam Chicken Size( Close To Cornish Game Hen That You'd Buy In The Grocery Store)
They Are Truely Large Quail--- And Have A Slightly Less Spaztic Personality--- The Trade Off? They Bite Alot Harder! Currently The Younger Batch Of Butlers I Have Now Are About 5 Mos Old And They Are At Least 25% - 35% Larger Than My 2 Yr Old Ga Giant Breeders. Both Birds Taste Alike For Meat, As Do The Wisconsin Jumbos , Northern Jumbo, Standard, Mexican Speckled, And Tennessee Reds--- When It Comes To Cooking A Bob Is A Bob Is A Bob.... Temperments Vary Somewhat With The Butlers Being Too Big To Spaz.
There Hopefully Will Be A New Strain Out For Our Perusing Pleasure This Year Or Next Thanx To Byc's Very Own "mad Scientist" Of Bob White Hybridization--- Charlie (wilds Of Pa) Has Designed A Bird He Is Calling The Slatebelt Monster Bob White From His Very Own Witches Brew Of Breeders--- Hope Fully He'll Be Able To Throw Some Eggs Out For Us To Set This Coming Spring