Can a New Layer Lay Two Eggs?

[MrsAuberry00]

My girls are confusing me... I'm sure it's on purpose. So, I witnessed a RIR laying this egg:

I already know what my two older girls' eggs look like. Yesterday I got a big egg with a black feather stuck to it, so that had to have come from my Marans Cross. That leaves another RIR to lay, and a few days ago I got two, same colored eggs from the same box pictured on each side of the darker egg:

Could these two eggs have come from the same layer in the same time frame? (They were collected at the same time,) otherwise, my cockerel is laying.

Chickens are hard.

 

[chickens really]

Yes, young layers can lay two eggs....Your Rooster is normal....lol.....

 

[aart]

Could these two eggs have come from the same layer in the same time frame?

Is the one on the left thin shelled?
Newly laying pullets can produce 2 eggs on the same day,
but usually one is soft or thin or oddly shelled.

 

[MrsAuberry00]

Is the one on the left thin shelled?
Newly laying pullets can produce 2 eggs on the same day,
but usually one is soft or thin or oddly shelled.

The one on the left was small and football shaped. I don't remember it being particularly thin shelled. We haven't had any eggs that are colored like that since.