Can this happen? Because it did.

[NatJ]

non of the Faverolles mixes off my orp boy have had extra toes- They've had all the other features though

Did the Faverolles parent have the extra toes?

If both parents have 4 toes per foot, all the chicks should too.
If at least one parent has 5 toes, and there are more than a few chicks, I would expect at least some chicks to have extra toes.

 

[lilwanderer]

Did the Faverolles parent have the extra toes?

If both parents have 4 toes per foot, all the chicks should too.
If at least one parent has 5 toes, and there are more than a few chicks, I would expect at least some chicks to have extra toes.

All my Faverolles have 5 toes. I didn't hatch that many from them so maybe that's why.

 

[NatJ]

All my Faverolles have 5 toes. I didn't hatch that many from them so maybe that's why.

Yes, that might be why.