I use the fluffing method, which I believe is what you refer to as the stirring method. I use a short handle rake with 3 long tines to fluff the litter up in the coop. Whether straw or pine shavings the poo is usually pretty dry within a short time frame. Fluffing makes it all fall to the bottom, meaning fewer full coop cleanings.
I would have suggested craigslist too but I see you already have. Good luck!!