I am interested...Great post! Very insightful and well spoken.
I know many of the OTs have left the thread and even have left the forum since the change. I like the thread to stay true, if I can get it, but I know it cannot because of lack of OT participation and lack of common sense of others. All one has to do is read the first post and it explains the tenor of this thread....if you have practical, common sense advice to give, give it~but please indicate how long you have been raising chickens so that someone can get a feel for how long you have put that into practice and gauge the method and results based on consistency of methodology.
If a method works for you but you've only had flocks for 1-2 years, then it may have validity but it may also not stand the test of time. For someone who only wants to raise chickens for a few years, it may indeed work and that's okay too...they can then use the advice knowing it may work for the duration of their husbandry efforts. It may last for longer and it may not...and that is their own risk as mileage may vary.
Speaking of myself, I've tried all kinds of different things the last few years that my ancestors didn't know or try...nothing major that changes the standard practices we've used for many years, but still valuable additions or methods that I plan to incorporate into my husbandry. Just the little things that I've tried and found useful. Did those things all come from the advice of OTs? Some of them but not all.
Everything we learn is somewhat useful...even if we don't use it.
Sideline: I am doing a new meaty batch this spring but I won't have one of my trusty broodies to help me so it ought to be interesting. I'm getting 40-50 chicks. I'm going to construct a cattle panel, portable coop structure to accommodate the chicks, grow out the birds(they will free range) and then it will be converted into a coop suitable for laying hens. The only wood I will use in this structure will be the wood framing at the base and the roosts. Should be interesting and I'll take some pics of the progress if anyone is interested. I'll start a new thread for all that.