in 30 years of raising chickens I have yet to worm one ....shoot my dogs and cats don't have them either . now don't get me wrong I don't do the natural thing that you all are talking about other than culling any sickly or weak growing birds.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I don't find that to be proof whatsoever....maybe proof that someone is not pairing natural deworming with the other things that make this type of deworming effective. Even Salatin pairs his natural deworming of his cattle with judicious culling and breeding for parasite resistance. Anyone serious about natural animal husbandry is going to take the time to choose breeds with natural resistance, select from those breeds in the flock who thrive on natural methods, cull those that do not and then breed for animals that carry that natural resistance along to their offspring.
One cannot just throw some herbs at a group of animals and then pronounce it doesn't work if the whole flock or even ANY of the flock just doesn't do well with those methods. If I tell you that I've never seen worms in any of the chickens I have killed and ate...and that is a full on plenty...that were raised with all natural methods, does this mean that it proves that it DOES work? Probably this would not be conclusive evidence for you. You would want to try it. But...if you also didn't spend years developing and refining your flocks to suit your methods, you probably would find that you too would state that "natural" deworming doesn't work.
There is more to natural husbandry than what you throw down an animal's throat or what you spread on their backs. If you want an easy method to raising some chickens, then buying something off a store shelf and placing it in the water seems like the best route for you. If you want to grow animals that don't HAVE to be given medicine in order to live out a year, then you want to put in a little thought and deliberation into your husbandry practices.
Easy methods pay off for short term results.
A little less easy, more thought, more planning....well, that pays off in the long run and in the long run it gets easier and easier.
You'll never see me posting how my whole flock got wiped out with some disease~has never happened and I don't attribute that to luck, but to hard won hardiness in my flock. You'll also never see me posting about my whole flock or any of it, getting wiped out in a predator attack because I've free ranged...I've taken the not so easy route so that my long term predator program is assured. I didn't just turn out my birds and cross my fingers that they will be safe...I've paired my free range with several safety measures.
I use the free range example because it is much like the natural deworming...someone throws some birds in the back yard, doesn't fence them with perimeter fencing, doesn't offer protection in the form of a dog or other protection animal, doesn't give them anywhere to hide, no rooster to give a warning....then they will come on the forum and emphatically state that they tried it, lost their birds in a tragic predatory attack and would NEVER free range a chicken again and anyone who does obviously doesn't care about their birds. I've seen those kind of posts over and over on this forum and each time it makes me want to scream.
With natural deworming, one has to use multiple approaches. Some of these include: Free ranging your flock. Culling for non-thriftiness(poor condition, performance, etc.). Multiple natural methods/sources of deworming(garlic, soap, wood ashes). Offering probiotics like UP/ACV to improve digestive and intestinal function and health. Non-medicated feeds always, from day one. Deep litter in the coop, summer and winter. No disinfectants for the equipment or housing. Good, whole grains and freshly milled feeds instead of prepackaged, pelleted feeds from bags that have been milled for some time and sitting in warehouses awaiting delivery.
Proof that I have done it properly is in the fact that I don't show up at the vet with a sick animal. That I don't even know what the symptoms of coryza are, nor any of the other diseases. I've never even researched them for educational purposes. Why? Because I don't intend to have them in my flocks....and I simply work on my husbandry until every bird is a picture of good health. Period.
You might just say I've been lucky but I believe in my husbandry methods and I feel that it isn't luck...it took determination to get there. Luck is when you do nothing and get good results. When you actually put time and effort and get good results, it should simply be called "successful". Calling something like that luck is like saying an Olympic gold medal winner is merely lucky.
Flagirl, what is it that you believe a rooster would protect your hens from ? In my experience, which is substantial, about the only thing a rooster can protect hens from is another rooster. Not from dogs, hawks, coyotes, racoons, mink and etc. He may offer an alternative food source for actual threats to the hens, but that is doubtful.