I am better at being a visual person. I've read and re-read the SOP for breeds I care about, over and over. Yet, my eye is better trained by seeing photos, old photos from the turn of the last century. I love those prints, those old photographs and old paintings. I can "see" the lines, the shape, the wing, the back, the legs, the head, feathering etc.
When Al, Bob, KathyinMo, NYreds, Walt and other really great breeders post photos of their birds, I can see immediately what they say in words, what they are going for in their breeding.
I hate pinched tails and narrow butts on hens, for example. Faults aren't all that easy to miss. Where the skill and experience comes in is in breeding to "fix" or correct faults. Breeding to maintain and propagate the good features. THAT is what I am just a freshman student when enroll in these experienced breeders discussions. I am at the place in life where I now have the time and the interest in such things. I'm afraid I have little to contribute, really. I'm just a newbie.
This is a drive by post...still have chores to do. This bird has a pretty big fault. the lower breast is flat as a board. Rocks should have an underline that is bowl shaped...roundish and here we have this flat spot just before the legs. This is not for appearance, that is where organs reside. This bird is showing a lack of capacity to correctly house some important body parts. Could be why it placed second. Schilling usually corrected some of that in his drawings/photo's, but maybe this guy wanted to show it the way it was. She is kind of crow headed too...better stop before I pick it totally apart.
Can ya see it Fred?
Walt