- Nov 8, 2011
- 278
- 16
- 101
I agree that her knowledge of chickens is minimal. Her knowledge of waterfowl is even worse. She's written some very misleading and incorrect information on ducks and geese. Her Chicken Health Handbook is the biggest waste of money and paper in my library. Part of that is the nature of many chicken diseases, but it takes a lot less space, and should cost you a lot less money, to say that many chicken diseases are very similar in appearance, it takes lab analysis, often through necropsy, to tell the difference, and many have no simple or reliable treatment. I will say that she does an excellent job with Rural Heritage magazine, and draft animals. She should stick with what she knows best.I can get it published for you.
Gail Demarow/Luttmann and I were partners in a printing venture in the 70's-80's and I can tell you that her knowledge of chickens is minimal, yet she churns out all kinds of poultry books. She just takes existing info and puts it in her cutesy way and the books sell like hotcakes. Her poultry management practices are nothing like the books....lol She also does a lot of ripping off of info from others.
Walt
A real charlitan of an author is that Sue Weaver. By many accounts she is a very lovely woman, but she has very little practical personal experience with the animals which she writes about, especially with long term sustainable production and exhibition. She owns one or two of this or that, mostly individual pets. Admittedly, most of her information is rehashed from internet searches which she does from her trailer all day. She advocates the anthropomorphism of most animals, including letting goats visit in the house and jump on the furniture, trying to house break them, diapering poultry to keep as house pets and other unsanitary childish practices. Her Guide to Raising Miniature Livestock preys on the ignorant and the gullible, misleading them to believe that many of the so-called minis are actually pure breeds, when in fact they are nothing more than recent crossbreeds, or naturally small individuals of a breed that may easily produce normal sized offspring. Shame on Storey's for falling for the hype and publishing that garbage.
Not all of Storey's books are bad. Many are quite good, if slightly outdated, but they are gradually working on updating them. Most of their larger livestock books have at least a good grasp of the basics to help get a novice started. Some of their newer color photo books which illustrate most of the breeds are very nice. They actually did it right and went to some of the larger livestock shows to photograph quality examples of many of the breeds, rather than just backyard stock or hatchery birds. Their Guide to Raising Ducks is the most complete and thorough basic livestock management book that I've ever read, and I've read hundreds. From what I've seen of his past writings, they made a good choice in Glenn Drowns to write an updated Guide to Raising Poultry. I haven't read the updated edition yet, but it was in need of a rewrite. Hopefully they didn't include too much of the old material. I do wonder how he found the time, seeing that he's always whining about how little he has, which is obvious if you've ever been one of his customers.