No...I agree on that point. I'd put some of my old BAs and my WRs up against any SOP, egg for egg, for their lifetime and I think I could be proud of her performance, as well as her mothering skills on brood. That they have survived on free range is also important to me, as well as with not having to have meds to stay alive and thriving. I'm not ashamed of my flocks...never have been. They are what they are and they have been good to me.
If I had to trade one of my WRs for an SOP gal right now, I wouldn't. Even if she never laid another egg, she has earned the right to live and die right where she started. I have a deep respect for a few of my hatchery gals. Had two of my oldest and most cherished BAs ripped up by a couple of young pups I adopted and it about broke my heart. I took out the gun and shot them the next day....the dogs, not the birds. I killed them also but held them while they died. It was a real shame...in their 6th year and still outlaying the youngsters.