As for what is "natural," chickens all come from jungle fowl that live near the equator and have roughly equal days and nights year round. They also naturally only lay a handful of eggs per year, and they naturally don't live in northern climates.
Over many hundreds of years humans have selected for more eggs, or bigger eggs, or stripy feathers, or bigger crests, or meaty breasts... Our dear domesticated birds are human creations that have been kept around for centuries to serve us, in exchange for us providing their basic needs.
I am lighting this year since all of my girls are young and just coming into lay. I will probably not light next winter in case someone needs a break. It doesn't seem to be a right or wrong thing to me, just individual choice or need.
I would personally rather encourage my healthy and pampered birds to make a few more eggs rather than giving a nickel to support the factory farms that would otherwise provide the eggs for my house and my neighbors.
Over many hundreds of years humans have selected for more eggs, or bigger eggs, or stripy feathers, or bigger crests, or meaty breasts... Our dear domesticated birds are human creations that have been kept around for centuries to serve us, in exchange for us providing their basic needs.
I am lighting this year since all of my girls are young and just coming into lay. I will probably not light next winter in case someone needs a break. It doesn't seem to be a right or wrong thing to me, just individual choice or need.
I would personally rather encourage my healthy and pampered birds to make a few more eggs rather than giving a nickel to support the factory farms that would otherwise provide the eggs for my house and my neighbors.