Conflicting gender signs-11 weeks

[spinweaver]

I have a pair of Americuana chickens, 11 weeks old. One has a pale, undeveloped comb AND a cock/sickle feather, the other has a red, larger comb and NO cock feather. The undeveloped comb chicken behaves rather aggressively. Please tell me if you think they are both roos! I really want hens.

 

[enola]

They are Easter eggers not Ameraucanas. The one that is mostly white is a cockerel. I believe the other one is a pullet.

 

[BantamLover21]

The mostly white one is a cockerel, but I think the other one is a pullet. Sometimes when pullets are growing in their adult plumage, they'll have what appears to be a pointed sickle feather. It isn't a true sickle, though, just an odd looking normal hen feather.

 

[spinweaver]

Well, thank you this is good news! The combs are quite different, so it makes sense that they are boy and girl- but that cock feather confused me!

 

[chickmomma03]

I have an EE pullet that has some pointy feathers too, she's definitely a she though.

I agree 2nd picture front is cockerel back is pullet.

 

[Farrier]

Whilst I agree that the comb growth and colour indicate pullet and I don't see any pointed saddle or hackle feathers, the red wing blotches are rather suspicious.

 

[enola]

I am looking at these pictures on my phone, so they don't show up as well on the screen. I can't see any red in wings.

Maybe OP will post pictures of the chickens in sunlight.