Okay, Fred said that without discussion, this breed would be closed and we would move on to something else. He also said he wanted some breeders to weigh in and to ask questions. I can't offer expertise, but I can sure as heck ask questions!
One of the first things I see that we need to be working on is size. The roosters are supposed to be 6lbs and the hens are supposed to be 4lbs. I have never even seen an American pic of a Campine that was close to that. In my limited knowlege, that is an easy process, you select the largest of the birds you hatch to use for breeders (as long as they have no DQs.) I understand the concept of "build the house before you add the paint" so I think that is one of our main areas of concentration, being careful not to sacrifice any true to type qualities that we already have.
The "good" Campines that I have seen (which is more accurately described as "best available") have a pretty good handle on earlobe, leg, and eye color. There are groups of Campines that are showing the side sprigs that Stvn mentioned, which is a DQ. Those all need to be culled. The combs without the side sprigs just need some tweeking for size and shape, but there are plenty that provide something to work with in that regard. I have seen tails on some of the roosters that are showing more sickles and saddle feathers than are desireable and hope that we will pay particular attention to retaining the hen feathering that is unique to this breed. The tail set is in need of attention, but I think that is an ongoing process in many breeds. Lastly, the barring is the area where I think the most work is needed. We are nowhere close to SOP on the feathering in terms of the correct ratios of black to white in any of the parts of the bird's body but especially in the tail, flight, and breast feathers.
What I really need (what I need some expert guidance in) is to learn to recognize the correct body shape (according to the SOP which I have read, but don't feel confident that I understand) and in determining which aspects of that should be given priority when selecting next year's breeders.
I have been hanging on Bob's everyword and know that I need a plan. My plan at this point is to hatch as many chicks as possible, provide them all with the best nutrition possible, cull all DQ's, then select the largest that have no glaring faults like saddle feathers, red earlobes, knock kneed, etc.
Any suggestions?