Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Managing Your Flock' started by shugaskull, Nov 21, 2011.
wouldn't caponizing, in essence, do the same thing?
Most of the operations are done under anesthesia, and I have seen several Roos after. They will be a little sore for a day or two but its just like getting over a sore throat. They are back to a happy life very quickly.
caponizing would take away the ability to have chicks so no its not the same thing
Quote:Good point.. that thought slipped my mind.
Good luck with this. I hope you can get something figured out
So, again, please if anyone has suggested medical texts to read I would appreciate more knowledge.
Caponizing is removing the testes, it would render them sterile. It is performed when they are still quite small (young) the complications on a grown roo are exponetially higher, and if they are already crowing likely will not stop the crowing. If there is any "slip" even the tiniest piece of one of the testes that is accidentally left in they will still crow and may or may not be sterile, but will still act like full roo.
Sorry I can't help w/ any articles or knowledge of surgical "de crowing" I never even knew it was possible.
Cruel or not, I believe shugaskull has seen all of the instances of this and for that reason in the very first post they said "Please keep opinions to your self, I am strictly looking for facts, research, reference materials (i.e. books, articles, medical texts, etc.....). " So whether it is cruel or not isn't important (in my opinion) currently. You could argue it over and waste time, or you could provide the information requested and allow people who read to decide their opinion regarding the subject. I don't think shugaskull's will be changed, as they've seen roosters after the procedures and have probably done some research as well.
I could see this thread going down hill quickly; even if some of the ones here haven't it is only a matter of time before someone comes along and starts an uproar I imagine. I wouldn't mind learning a little bit more on the subject myself. I would never do it, but I wouldn't mind learning about how it is done and so on for the next person who comes along.
Note: This post is not directed at any one person, it is just an opinion of a opinion I guess one could say .
I know where I live we don't have any vets in our area that are capable of completing surgery on chickens or any other birds. I would have to go two counties over to do that. I am very interested in what you find out though. Medically if it can be done humanely it might be a way that people living in city areas can have roosters for breeding without causing problems with their neighbors. Definitely an interesting idea.
Thank you Daniel for bringing the thread back to the heart of knowledge. Hopefully someone on this forum has some experience on decrowing and can share their education.
LilyD do you have the name of that vet that is two counties away so i can contact them for info?