I have read on here they can`t hatch. That is why I was asking if they were doomed. The air cell is firm now. They were wobbling around like jelly at first.What exactly are you asking? If the eggs with the saddle shaped air cells are doomed because they were on their sides for the first 7 days? If so, then no. They are not doomed.
Are the air cells still loose? Or have the re-attached?
No, the cartons don`t have holes cut in them. Should I do that? I think I saw a few people said not to bother. Did you keep the eggs upright to hatch, or lie them down Doug?Did you cut the bottoms out of the egg carton? Did you candle to make sure that the air cell is on top? Sounds like you are doing it right. Im sure others will chime in. I had a decent hatch of saddle shaped eggs the last time.