i am just offering advice, here - there is more than one way to think about $150/doz hatching eggs. i have paid more than that for eggs, this is meaning to inform; not to offend.
by spending that on a common breed like black cochin bantams, and knowing the breeder; you will be certain to get some very nice stock. if you are planning on showing, this is an excellent way to get the chickens you need. you have also opened the door to someone who is knowledgeable in the breed and knows your lines. his knowledge is invaluable to you. the down side is not all chicks will be show quality, and breeding a show quality trio is not always the best way to go. you should have enough diversity with your group to be fine.
another way of looking at it is, if you bought $150 in live chicks you can control your cockerel/pullet ratio (through some places). you should be able to find them from a "good" breeder for $5 (or less) each. you wont have as many show quality, but you have alot more to select from. selling the extras at the right times can pay for the ones you decide to keep, and the feed bill for them to that point. of course if your wanting to show, this could put you a generation off. but you will certainly end up with respectable breeding stock.
if your not looking to show, or breed for show it really wont matter where you get them from. you will still enjoy watching them out in your yard and hearing the rooster crow in the morning.
just food for thought, and decisions i have to make all the time.
Yes, I want them for breeding and I hope to begin showing.
His breeding stock is excellent and there are no doubts in my mind that whatever hatches will become good quality breeders, however, not all the chicks will become top notch show birds. You correct that the breeder's knowledge will be an in-valuable resource. He has been breeding his line of black cochins for well over 50 years.
Chicks from other sources probably won't be of the quality I'm searching for. Thanks for posting; it definitely gave me some things to think about.
Last edited: