I believe they will try again, but to make the next one work why not give 1 broody a chance at hatch by giving her her own space. My Muscovy's will not tolerate another one getting anywhere near their nest so I don't have that problem but when one or more do sit the same nest things just like this happen not any ones fault but the ducks start jostling around and an egg gets cracked before time and the duckling hatches before it's ready. So to make it a great experience for everyone including you next time give first to go broody her own little space. My ducks sleep in stalls so when one goes broody she has her own space which has worked out well except a couple of my girls share one and that means I have to find the kicked out duck her own sleeping space. Thankfully I have a small coop[chickens first house] that has worked as sleep over till brood is up. I just keep the door open to the stall that way they can come and go as they want too. Sometimes the other girls will slip in and lay their eggs in a nest so I mark all egg laid so I can keep up with fresh ones and won't have any duckling half cooked when the first hatch and get left in the nest. Hope next time you'll be reward with some ducklings nothing sweeter than a mama with babies in tow.She was the last and the only one to hatch out. All the others quit at various stages and a few infertiles went rotten. A community of 4, one drake and 3 ducks, just turned a year old. They were all by appearances and observation, dedicated but I left them be until day 21, not wanting to disrupt their instincts to see if they'd take hold. It wasn't planned, the first duck went broody and I decided to let her, then the others followed, even the drake but he's only ever known his girls so he's a pretty nice drake.
In hindsight I've read a lot where the community thing can go awry and why. And sometimes it works. I don't regret letting them try, they were amazing to watch in their bonded determination. I'm sad that it didn't work out because they didn't get the end result of ducklings so I don't know if they will ever brood successfully after that. I work with rescue dogs so I may be over thinking the duck's reaction but it kinda makes sense, they are bonded animals.
Let us know if it happens.
