You are good now. I didn't realize your birds were nearly 5 months old. Really you can offer it any time if it is in a separate container since birds that don't need it will usually avoid it. Pullets reach sexual maturity at different rates, especially now we're after summer solstice. Their bodies will usually tell them when they need to start shoring up calcium for the impending need.I'll try the after-dark thing. Or maybe just wait and see when they do it. When does one start offering them free choice oyster shells???