i hated rose, she was too whiney for me..... and i agree with you on the Rory side of the spectrum, the poor guy, never gets a happy ending.....Ditto. They are so different it's hard to compare. I loved Eccleston, but my daughter, husband and brother-in-law didn't care for him. Rose annoyed me and I agree that Clara just isn't likeable enough. I loved pond and poor poor Rory![]()