I truly don't think I am heavy handed, as she does ride infinitely better off legs rather than hands. She is extremely light in the mouth. My husband and I have had a few 'lively discussions' about this, as I feel he carries his hands too high and uses them too much. On one occasion I could see that he was aggravating her, and she ended up sulling up and alternating between bucking and rearing. Luckily for him she stopped after she'd unseated him. I'm not brave but wanted to prove a point, got on her and had no issues at all. I know he knows more than me, but even a blind squirrel finds a nut every now and then.
I grew up riding English and only recently switched to Western, which gave me more than a few problems when coupled with overcoming my fear of horses. The last thing I wanted to do was have long loose reins when i'd been taught to maintain contact! If I became nervous, my first reaction was to pick up on the reins which usually caused me more problems. Equally, the western saddle felt like riding a saddle rather than riding a horse.
After going through several ranch horses that I could not get along with, I finally convinced my husband to let me get my own. The main problem I had with those was that they were set in their ways; if I went to move cattle on them I didn't have a problem. Trying to ride away from the house or in the arena they gave me fits, and I couldn't learn and gain confidence from a horse that would act out whatever I did. I had no way of telling when it was me and when it was the horse. So along came Lucy, not exactly what I had been looking for but that's a whole different story that has a lot to do with someone else's opinion of what I needed.
Lucy is nowhere near the minx she was when we bought her. I was too scared to even lead her. Not because she would try to hurt me, but she had no 'bubble' and I was worried she'd run into me. She has never threatened to kick, bite, paw. She does not try to hurt people, but her tantrums have the potential to. If she was aggressive she'd be long gone. Her moods change like the wind, but I don't find her unpredictable; she will not randomly buck or rear, it is always the same scenario that causes it.
She'll usually rein without even holding the reins. The problem comes when she doesn't want to, and the reins are used as reinforcement. It almost exclusively happens to the left. She braces and pulls against them, throws her head, turns it to the right and runs sideways. She can also have an attitude if she anticipates wrongly and is corrected, she's almost like a teenager that's tried to do something helpful and is offended when you tell them it's not.
She doesn't have wolf teeth, but she does have very small canines. They are less than 1/10" long. They are loose and the vet said they will most likely just fall out.
Switching to the hackamore has almost eliminated the problem. She did it a few times for the first couple of rides, but I think it was habit more than anything. The only time she has given me trouble was the day I tried using a bit again. She was in heat but her behaviour was unacceptable, I know I should have ridden her through it until she was wanting to listen, but my fear got the better of me and I didn't get much help that day. That was the only time she has been in a bit since her teeth were floated, and she was rotten in anything I tried to ride her in.
For the record, we have not been 'going to a more aggressive bit'. We've done the opposite. In a perfect world it would be great to just use another horse if the one you have isn't perfect. However, finances and training come into the equation. We can't keep Lucy and buy another.
Rusty I believe you are exactly right. She is too smart to do 'boring' work. The quickest way to calm her down is to give her a more difficult task. It helps me too, giving me something else to focus on other than what her ears are doing! Working cattle in the arena is like tranquilising her, I can feel she is completely relaxed. She's the strangest creature I have ever come across; the harder the task, the better she behaves. It is incredibly frustrating because I know she knows the basics, she's just too ADD to behave. She should do whatever is asked of her.
I agree it sounds like i'm aiming for the impossible with her, but if i didn't have some faith i'd have quit long ago. The reasoning behind wanting to use her for this event is the diversity, it seems to cater to her need for stimulation. There are five components: trail, cutting, reining, conformation, and riding. It's also something I love to do, and have the facilities for. For the past few clinics I have used my stepmother in law's horse (as she had ACL surgery) and she and I get along famously (the horse that is
). However, we can't show the same horse and I can't afford one with the degree of training that hers has.