Soooo good to see this post. I have had a CONSTANT broody momma (occasionally another joins her) and no matter what, I could NOT break her of it. I tried everything. I didn't think our adopted rooster was ... well, "active"..... so bought 15 day old chicks this year. My husband and I decided to get a much larger chicken house than the one we had built and been using. All our adult hens (and rooster) were still up in the original hen house. We had built into the new house a little area separated (but included) where we hoped to have a broody momma sit and raise her babies. Then I decided to get 12 (hopefully) fertilized eggs from a neighbor and moved the broody into the new house with the eggs. She refused to sit on them!!! Argh!!!!! I put her back in the old hen house, and she went right back to her favorite (high) nesting box and remained broody. ok. SO, apparently she did not want to move. Despite my conviction that our rooster is nothing but a free-loader, I decided to let her keep 13 eggs that were laid in her box and she claimed. She discarded 2 right away. Yesterday was day 12 and 8 of the remaining 11 were FERTILE!!!! Yahoo!!! This might work! They were so dark that I could not tell if they were all alive, but we are hoping!
So obviously we had some of the same questions.... when to move her and the babies down to a safe level, especially. Given her earlier refusal to move and quitting (actually just not accepting) the eggs, I was thinking about holding off on their move til day 2 after they are hatched. What do you all think????? And total frustration: I have to be gone for 2 days, starting on their due date! Double Argh. My husband will be here ...but.....but.... I wanna be!