Wow very similar !i got pepper from a guy across town. She has skate legs. Lays cream smaller eggs. Not bantam but smaller then my EE's. I'm curious how long has she been laying before she went broody? She always been my mystery hen. Smaller, smart and head of pecking order ! Must have some of the same blood. Almost everything about them look alike . I'm going to see if I can find chick pic ? Do you have one?My girl is an EE, she has the green/slate legs and lays blue/green eggs. I got her from McMurray. I did wonder at first if she wasn't one of the ones you mentioned since I got a mystery chick from the hatchery and she looked different and stood taller as a chick than my other EEs but she answered my question when she started laying. Turns out my mystery chick was just another EE, which was an awesome because they are one of my favorite breeds, with Orpingtons being my other favorite. Such sweet personalities with both of the breeds!
If yours lays brown eggs maybe she is an EE that just lays brown eggs, I hear that happens sometimes, or she could be a cross? They do look like sisters though!
Last edited: