So I have an update on my Easter Eggers from Ideal. 4 of  the 7 chicks that I got from them looked similar. I knew one was a Welsummer. Two looked a lot alike, so I assumed they were the Easter Eggers (picture of one above) and the one who was a little different was the Olive Egger.
Then I saw Olivia, my presumed Olive Egger, lay a blue egg. So one of the two almost identical chickens is my Olive Egger and the other is an Easter Egger.
I want to call in sick to work until I watch them all lay an egg so I can solve this once and for all.
View attachment 4086786Olivia. Former Olive Egger, now Easter Egger anove. And below is of two identical chickens, one of whom lays an olive egg and one who lays blue.
So apparently what they look like has nothing to do with what color egg an Easter Egger lays.
View attachment 4086788