EEs are so hard to sex - please help!

teach1rusl

Love My Chickens
16 Years
Joined
Jul 28, 2009
Messages
10,068
Reaction score
369
Points
506
Location
Floyds Knobs, Indiana
My Coop
My Coop
I've seen lots of EE sexing help posts recently, so I know it's not just me. Usually I'm very good at distinguishing pullets from cockerels early on, but two out of three of my easter egger chicks really have me confused (and nervous). They are "supposed" to be pullets (from MPC/Meyer), and are 5 weeks old. Maybe you color experts can help????

1) Nobody's legs are any thicker/thinner than the others - they all look thickish compared to my two non EE chicks.
2) All have very horizontal body lines when they run around and or just perch somewhere.
3) All feathered out very quickly.
4) I only see a center row of peas/ridge looking stuff at this point, not three rows. But maybe the three rows pop up later??

BUT…two of them have off and on pinkish/orange brightness to their combs, and I think that's a BAD thing. Sometimes their combs look "normal" and other times they really stand out (kind of like Rudolf's nose going on and off, although not quite that bright…lol). The third EE chick has a plain ole (safe) yellowish colored comb all the time.

Based on my reading, I think at least Molly's coloring indicates pullet (rather plain brown/ tan w/salmon breast). Xena has me a little more worried, because her feathers look very pretty, bright to me, which makes me think cockerel. But again, the sometimes bright combs are what's really worrying me about both these two.

Here's Autumn, whom I'm 99.9% sure is a pullet. Her comb looks plain old yellow. She's my largest EE chick. Coloring, comb, everything screams pullet:
37862_sept_25_2011_031.jpg

37862_sept_25_2011_028.jpg

Here's Molly, my plainest looking EE chick at this point, color seems safe, but the comb sometimes turns bright:
37862_sept_25_2011_057.jpg

37862_sept_25_2011_050.jpg

Here's Xena, my favorite, her coloring worries me, plus that on/off baby aspirin comb color. She's the smallest of my EEs:
37862_sept_25_2011_036.jpg

37862_sept_25_2nd_set_030.jpg

Xena w/safe Autumn
37862_sept_25_2nd_set_015.jpg


No good shots of their combs, but all (so far) have single peas/ridge through the center... Thanks for your input!
 
The feather color of the birds in all your pics is a commonly found color/pattern in EE girls.
smile.png
 
OMGosh!!! I sure hope you guys are right about Xena!!
fl.gif
She's really the one I've worried most about. I've only had one EE in the past, and her comb stayed yellow forever, so I was so bummed when two of my little ones' combs began looking orange/pink around the 4 week mark. And it didn't make sense to me (still doesn't actually) why it'd look fairly yellow one minute, but bright the next. Plus Xena was my plainest chick, and then began feathering out so brightly, so I've been driving DH crazy stressing over her. I'll be SO happy/relieved if you guys are right
ya.gif
 
I agree they all look like pullets. My EE's comb was pink from the very beginning, so I wouldn't let that worry you.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom