My EE looks like your...the one with the pinkish egg....and mine lays pinkish eggs, too!I should note too, that they were all from the same clutch..and I purposely picked out 4 of the most different looking chicks...thinking for sure that I would get a roo..(the prettiest chicks always seem to be roosBut she was fairly adept at gender (about 90%) and I trusted her. Guess she did good by me!