In our area, a dozen brown eggs sells @
WalMart for $2.46. Cage Free, Organic brown eggs $4.29.
So.... I feel like everyone I sell to is getting a great deal:
I sell my girls eggs at different prices actually.....
People at church $1.50 dozen when they provide a carton ($2 without a carton).
People at work $2.00 dozen with a carton ($2.50 without).
Strangers and so-forth $3.50 straight up, but I provide a new clean unused carton (that I buy for $.48 each plus tax)
The reason I charge differently is because I have different relationships with all these people. Also, I give eggs away to my neighbors and family. My hens are quite generous.
Now that we are in the fall molt and laying MUCH less, I just tell everyone the factory is closed for the season, lol.
I agree with a previous poster...look at craigslist and the local newspaper before you decide how much you want to charge. At least make enough to buy the feed to support your girls.