Egg washing myth

The way I understand it, commercial hatcheries wash their eggs. I don't know what chemicals or what concentration of those chemicals they use. Yes that can remove some of the bloom which nature relies on to protect the eggs but they are not having a broody hen hatch them. It is a controlled environment.

Washing the eggs is only a part of their sanitation/sterilization protocol. Before the eggs go in the room, the entire room and all of the equipment is thoroughly cleaned and sanitized. Access to the incubation and hatching rooms is controlled. Biosecurity measures are high, such as changing clothing before anyone goes in. Fumigation is part of the protocols.

I don't hatch like that. I clean my incubator before I start with a bleach solution to sterilize it. I keep my hands clean when I handle the eggs or equipment. I use tap water and a clean container when adding water. I do not set dirty eggs. A light dusting isn't bad but I avoid eggs with globs of dried poop or mud.

A poultry science professor that works with commercial hatcheries said they get about a 90% hatch rate of eggs set. About 5% never start developing. Another 5% quit before they hatch. I don't do that well. I get about an 80% hatch rate of eggs set from my flock. I candle just before they go into lockdown. My hatch rate of the eggs that go into lockdown is much better but that's not the important one for me.

@Project Blue I'm glad you are getting good healthier hatches. It is my opinion (and only an opinion) that deformities are caused by other things than washing or not washing eggs (heredity, nutrition of the breeding/laying flock, or incubation temperatures for example). Washing the eggs is more about the bloom which is there to keep bacteria out. If bacteria gets inside the shell it kills the embryo and turns the egg rotten. I have never had a rotten egg in my incubator. I have under a broody, horrible. These correlations can be hard to make. These things can be complicated, You may not always know why some hatches are better than others. I hope your success continues.
 
It is my opinion (and only an opinion) that deformities are caused by other things than washing or not washing eggs (heredity, nutrition of the breeding/laying flock, or incubation temperatures for example). Washing the eggs is more about the bloom which is there to keep bacteria out.
In the past I mostly hatched shipped eggs and also think nutrition may be a factor. Currently I'm hatching eggs from the beginning of the season from fresh hens. I'm pretty sure hens get tapped out towards the end of a laying season no matter how well you feed them, especially when they are making new feathers. I recently bought feed store chicks and noticed their legs were thinner than mine at the same feather development.
 
Oh, dear. Let me be clear, I'm experimenting and liking the results, and what I'm doing here is sharing the results. The experimenting started with desperation as I lost my flock to a pit bull and was trying to recreate it with every single egg. The only thing I'm convinced about is washing eggs can be a good thing with hydrogen peroxide. Actually, I'd be afraid to use bleach or dish detergent. In the past, even with a good hatch there would be a good chance for a slow hatching weak chick. Now I'm getting all strong chicks. Correlation, causation unrelated assumptions, whatever, but it is useful to speculate as to why. I think my results are valid based on the hatch rates and health of the chicks that HP makes washing possible, not that it should be done, especially with clean eggs. Additionally, adding a little HP during incubation might be preventing now likely porous eggs from going bad. Most cleaners would be detrimental to fetal chick health, but I think HP is mostly benign. Why I think it's important to be able to incubate dirty eggs? If you are trying to breed a specific trait or in my case recover a certain line of chickens, every egg is important if you're collecting from one hen or two hens. I've heard over and over washing eggs is not a good idea because it removes the natural barriers keeping the embryo in a sterile environment necessary for the chick to develop. What I'm saying you can wash eggs with HP and get excellent results, not household cleaners. All my incubators are full and yes statistically it's still a small number, but I think it's enough to look into. There are so many factors incubating process that decide results. However, from one person's point of view that has used the same techniques from years of hatching, (I hatch yearly for decades) to see a major improvement is significant. The other thing is not all my incubators are equal in quality but all are getting good hatches.
Okay, point taken. I just thought it might be another protocol to try.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom