Thank you so much for your input! The cock closest to the front is actually my favorite too. I can only tell him apart because he has a crease on his left eye from an injury when he was a chick.
Well not to tell my whole life story, but right now we're expecting our first baby in Spring and I'm trying to cut back on my breeding projects. On the chopping block are either my Salmon Faverolles or Mottled Javas. My other project is blue laced red Wyandottes. Most of what I know is about BLRW. I have a copy of the SOP book that I reference but I am definitely still learning what to look for in the Favs.
The 5 males and the darker colored pullet are from Piperomar. I hatched the split-wing female from Sahwithchicks about 1.5 years ago, there was also a male from that batch that I culled because he was unusually aggressive. Prior to that I also had another shipped batch of eggs that didn't hatch (one did, but I culled the chick for foot problems). Overall I feel like I have been trying to get Salmon Favs started for about 2 years and keep having really bad luck. They are one of my favorite breed personality and looks wise. I don't plan to show the birds, I'm just a hobbyist but I also want to do it right.
I know about pullet and cockerel lines, but I didn't realize that was standard in Favs. I would honestly like a pullet line more than a cockerel line, which it sounds like I have
What I know from BLRW is to breed for type first, which often means disregarding color at first.
I also have learned to practice line breeding, or inbreeding as you say. Why is that not acceptable for Faverolles? Is it because you are producing a pullet and a cockerel line? From what I know line breeding is the best way to get certain traits locked in and then you breed back to one of the parents for a generation or so before using one of the offspring to replace the (grand)parent.
I really appreciate your thoughts and critiques of my birds, thank you!
I would love to get more, but I'm not sure where to look now. I guess Piperomar's are a male line mostly. Cloverleaf farms was the other Fav breeder I had my eye on but she had to get rid of all her birds

Shipped eggs have just been so frustrating with low hatch rates that I want to buy from someone locally (Oregon).
It is frustrating that after so many failed attempts I still don't have good genes to breed with and so I am considering not breeding Favs at all.
I am interested why Faverolles are not line bred as I have learned with my other breeds.
It sounds like the unrelated hen shouldn't be considered at all, so she'll stay in the egglaying flock.
Almost all the cockerels have tails that look like that.. There is one that is wider in the tail, he's the one who had an injured eyelid when he was a chick and it's stayed that way. He can close his eyes but it looks weird. He's easy to pick out of the crowd at least. They are still in the skitish phase, they keep their distance from me, but I'll try to get them banded and get better photos of them sometime soon.
My choice now boils down to eliminating the Favs or the Javas... I enjoy the Favs a LOT more, but I think my Javas have less faults overall.