It's funny - in a recent conversation I had with someone regarding the benefits of feeding FF, their hang-up seemed to be with the fact that the FF is only fed 1-2 times a day as opposed to continuously free fed. This gentleman seemed very proud of the fact that his girls were able to eat "as much as they wanted" throughout the day. He was a much older gentleman and I wonder if he is one of those who is of the mindset that quantity equals affection. In fact, his attitude about it reminded me of something I heard once describing the generational gaps:
Today's generation asks, "Is it pretty?"
Their parents ask, "Did it taste good?"
Their grandparents ask, "Did you get enough?"
I have no clue if this has anything to do with why someone may choose to not feed FF. I'm just pondering out loud... Maybe they just think it's harder than it really is?
I think you are right...for many years now I've noticed that people keep continuous feeds out for their pets...for some reason they think this is normal nutrition for these animals? Do they feel guilty about having three meals a day and unlimited grazing abilities when their pets do not? Or is it the general equating pets with humans thing that always rears its ugly head?
When I was young a person never even bought dog food or cat food and neither one was kept in the house. Animals ate the scraps from humans and if it wasn't enough, they went hunting or scavenging. They lived healthy, long lives and never required vetting. I don't even recall giving wormers back then. Funny how times have changed...some think for the better?
They actually can do continuous feed for their chickens by putting out enough in the morning to last the birds all day long, so that's a non-issue. I think it's just laziness or the fear of trying something different from the herd.
I've been doing FF for 3 months now. I do agree that there is less waste with FF, and the girls poo is not as smelly. Basically, I add water and layer crumble to the stuff remaining in the bottom of the 1 qt container I ferment it in. (Original culture was started with ACV) By the next morning, it's pretty bubbly. I usually keep 2 qts going at a time. I have not added any whole grains. But I do have some BOSS, and some "wild bird seed" consisting of cracked corn, milo, and BOSS. If I add that to my FF mix, how much longer should I allow it to ferment, and is there really a benefit of adding the whole seeds to my current mix. My girls only get dry feed when I run out of FF. It doesn't seem that they have a particular preference. However, I read an experiment done by a fellow raising meat birds. He used FF on one group, and regular dry feed on the second group. His outcome was actually better with the second group, though the FF group was off to a slow start as they didn't initially take to the FF. Has any one done any further studies comparing the outcome of FF to dry feed? (in relation to chick growth, and expense of feed)
Many unofficial studies have been done in the backyards of flock owners on this but wouldn't exactly qualify as a "study"...just basic experimentation and weighing the results. I usually compare my chick growth and feed usage on meaties to those who are feeding dry for the same amounts of time...it always comes out favorable, though can't really be considered a "study".
The real success is in the overall experience. I fed out 54 meat birds for 1/4 the amounts of feed and expense that others did and had comparable finish weights and had even more savings because of no mortality due to health issues. Saved on bedding in the coop because of lack of moisture and smell in the feces. Saved on time with water usage as the water usage was way down. The weight on my birds was due to just lean, packed on meat, whereas much of the finishing weights on traditionally grown meaties can be attributed to a lot of fat in the skin and tissues. So the savings is showing up there as well...no one needs that much fat in their diet nowadays.
A slower and longer grow out is desirable in the meat birds if one wants healthier and more flavorful meat with a better texture, so that's a win/win also, IMO.
The benefit to adding whole grains to the layer ration, for me, is that I can cut the cost of feeding 100% layer rations in the times of year that they are not laying as much by adding a lower protein/lower cost grain to my mix so that they still get bulk and crude fiber, but not as much proteins they do not need. This saves me money and it's the only reason I do it, as my layer mash source has all the needed nutrients for poultry life and production, so adding grains to it aren't doing anything in the way of increasing nutrients.
In the fall I add some BOSS for more fats so that they can lay on some fat before winter, like most animals do. During the slow times I'll add barley to cut the ration and maybe oats if they are cheaper at the time. It's a way of feeding cheaper and improving the variety of grains consumed...if my birds were in a coop/run situation this is something I'd be doing but I'd be sprouting the grains instead so that they can actually receive greens for the winter. Mine free range all winter, so I don't need to do that.