Bee, we are going to have to agree to disagree. Your arguement sounds thought out and reasonable but is not based on fact. If you took my poo in and had it checked, there would be no worms. Seriously, I had worms when I was kid and you know it when you have worms! Worm treatments are safe and effective and I can't believe if you found you had worms in YOU you would up the garlic, pumpkin seeds, DE, whatever to keep your worm load down. Then if it got too bad cull then?
BTW, if you treat properly, and that means follow up treatments as prescribed, you will eliminate all worms. I CAN see that if not treated properly a drug resistant worm could be created. Done correctly all worms will be killed......I am living proof of that.
Yes, we will have to disagree. And my words are very based on fact...not my own, it's there for the reading in many places if you but search. I'm a nurse...I know just how accurate the O&P tests truly are...one has to have quite a load to be detected with those, so you'll have to go a long way to convince me on that one.
Worm treatments are safe and effective? Depends on your perspective...is it short range or long range? And, yes, you can believe that I wouldn't take them if I had worms...because I KNOW I have worms. We all do. I eat garlic nearly every meal and I have a bag of pumpkin seeds in my cupboard.
Mostly because they are tasty but also because they are part of a healthy diet that discourages parasites. I also eat fermented foods and keep an acid pH in my intestines.
Now, I'm curious as to how you know you have eliminated ALL worms with your follow up treatments? The only way you could know that is if you actually dissected the animal's bowels and examined them under a microscope to see that every single tiny worm was gone.
Nope...that dog don't hunt. People do that because other people and the back of the box says to do so, but they do not truly do any study on the situation. It's all knee jerk flock management that takes no extra thought or study to get to the root of the problem and the most effective way to solve it.
But...you keep doing what you do if it suits your fancy and you like it, and I'll keep doing what I do because it's been successful for almost 4 decades now and has been successful for many a farmer before me.
I just answered the lady's question because she asked and didn't come here for an argument. Apparently her vet...you know the one that has been trained in animal medicine?...agrees with me.