Quote from galefrances:
Very well put. Sometimes the kindest thing you can do for an animal is to kill it. Just because you buy land and have a place to keep animals, doesn't mean you should keep animals. And if you feel you want or need to, then I think you need to be willing to take on every responsibility that it entails, including ending suffering when necessary. It's never pleasant or fun, but it's just one of those things that has to be done sometimes. That is hard for some people to wrap their heads around when they didn't grow up seeing the cycle of life and death on the farm.This is why I teach these things....this is an important part of keeping animals, particularly livestock. Vets don't often treat chickens and they are easy to dispatch at home when they are suffering.
Gale, it was most certainly not meant to offend in any way and I certainly never meant to be mean to you....I value your input to these threads and think you are a wonderful person. That opinion is just mine and doesn't have to be adopted by you or anyone but it is something which I have had experience with in people that I know, even family. All that I have known who are reluctant to kill animals are also those who let them suffer out of that reluctance and those who also will not kill to improve their flocks...another thing that usually leads to animal suffering.
This whole forum is full of posts about those who will not kill a suffering animal but will treat it mercilessly until it finally dies...all the while it suffers while they get pats on the back for their heroic efforts to "treat" the bird. I'm not a big fan of this type of animal husbandry. Treating simple things like parasites and poor conditioning is quite different than something that is causing a bird to need a quick death.
It makes no matter how you are raised, when stepping into the realm of raising livestock it takes some fortitude and..yes..a grown up attitude about reality. An animal could be suffering at 2 am in the morning...will you then call up the person you have hired to kill your animals to get them to come out to kill your chicken? It's not a realistic scenario and I'm sorry if it offends you if I am practical in my teaching this concept. Eventually when you keep these animals there will come a time to kill...will you always have your back-up plan in place or will you do what is necessary, as any adult should?
It was said in a teasing tone to your post but it had a true message. As an adult, we have to do a lot of things that disturb us and cause us emotional grief. That's life and not very often you can duck out of that when things don't go the way you planned.
I would hope that you could see past your hurt feelings over this difference in our opinions and accept my apologies for hurting your feelings...it was not meant as a personal attack on you, Gale. I wish you could have seen some of the things I have seen when it comes to adults who will not ease the suffering of an animal because they cannot kill an animal...it would turn your knees to water and your heart to a weighty stone in your chest for the "feelings" of these people. You could then maybe understand why I hold this concept so dear.
Some things are worse than death and sometimes true compassion means you get tough and give the hand of mercy to those animals you hold dear.