Your experience is a good example of how different ways of management can all produce excellent results.
I prefer the natural self-cleaning of the deep litter environment (my preferred substrate being pine straw since it's free for the raking in my yard). I have enough work to do cleaning my house and don't want to have to add continually cleaning up after my chicken. My run has no odor and I don't track manure unless I accidentally step in a fresh lump.
I believe that, as creatures of the forest floor, a deep litter system best imitates chickens' natural environment. But as I wrote in my article on
Deep Bedding, there are valid points against it.
I encourage anyone who isn't happy with their current management method to try another method to see if it suits their personality and philosophy better.