From what I have read it sounded like they did dispute this. Some of these cities are really stupid when it comes to poultry. We live by Lexington KY. There you can have chickens, even roosters, as long as a HOA does not have rules against it. We used to live in Georgetown, about 15 minutes away and much more rural and a small town. A town were 10 years ago there were chickens running around city side streets. Well they have a NO poultry rule. And they are not nice about it. I had mine there because nobody ratted on me and was told (by animal control) that as long as I had hens and no one complained I should be okay. But then I lived in a flood plain, backed up to the Elkhorn and I-75 and was like a ghetto (seriously bad neighborhood) so people left me alone. But others who have had neighbors complain have been forced to get rid of their animals. One lady had hers on Craigs List. Said she had them for years but lost her fight with code enforcement. Really stinks. But your neighbor can have 30 plus cats, breeding on the roof of your car, yowling all night long, destroying your flower beds with urine and feces, spraying your front entryway and in general making life miserable and the city will do NOTHING. I know as my neighbor when there had those cats. They were all over, on her house roof, on the porch in the road, etc. And so many litters of kittens each year. I complained to the city, animal control and the humane society. I was told there is no rules on feral cats and that I could give her a voucher for spay and neuter at reduced prices. What a joke. Same with barking dogs. But chickens, they are somehow worse. I just don't understand.
This thread just makes me really sad. 28 years is a long time to invest in something and have it ripped out from you. It all seems so unfair.