Hi, hope you are enjoying BYC!
Where are their tail feathers?

It's hard to tell the angle at which they are holding it without those.
I wouldn't even be close to choosing yet... things change so drastically still not only in color but also attitude. And my real suggestion would be hatch some more!

And if they are your only two choices, sometimes I keep both in case something happens to one I will have a back up. But I keep a stag pen so my ladies aren't over mated.
# 2 has major difference in waddle sizes.
Watch out for the short pinky toe. Side sprigs, split wing and so on.
Here is a good resource for learning the SOP for Marans...
http://www.maransofamericaclub.com/black-copper-marans.html
Did you know that the offspring will get the egg shade from their sire? So having your boy have a nice egg color gene will effect your outcome of all future generations. (not to sound so dire!)
I think their eyes are too light. And # 2 might have some white feathers on his drivers side thigh, or it could be a trick of the camera and lighting.
Seriously though... I'm still learning to, and assure you I've got NO room to judge other's birds!
Have fun on your adventure! The learning never stops.
