The blackened bits will likely ALWAYS drop off. The key is to try to prevent the frostrite before it happened. Have you tried bag balm BEFORE the freeze to see if it adds enough protection to keep the frost bite away? I'd give that a try next time. Keep areas that's dropped off clean and the birds should be fine. Are they getting frost bit inside their house or when they go out? I'd try the bag balm. For the rest of the season and see if it helps. Best wishes
Me thinkest thou dost naught understand the severe cold and humidity we endure. Avoiding frostbite is not possible for many of us.
We easily hit 35-40 below, I it will be snowing at 15 below, humidity will be 70 %.. There is nothing you can do, to prevent frostbite and winter dubbing that will not cost a fortune.
Oils and udder balm help some, but on a large single comb it is useless. I have one rooster out of 100 birds or more with single combs that is whole. I do not want to even know what it cost me to keep his in one piece.
I used a heat lamp on his cage. I have 2 heating pads above his roost about 2 inches from his comb. I give him water in a small dish he can barely get his beak in so he does not get his waddles and comb wet. I have bag balm on him all winter, his feathers feel dirty from the bag balm running down or being smeared on him.
My wife just asked me last night " why is the electric bill $225 for the pole barn...... I did not dare answer so I went to the ol' reliable " How should I know?"
Even at that I had blood everywhere yesterday with the warm up, the very tip of one point of the comb is nicked. Hopefully no judge will notice it next year. He is my show Speckled Sussex or he would be like all the others wearing a Minnesota Cushion Comb.
Matter of fact I have a Dominique rooster with a rose comb and the points are frozen off this year. I have a 3 year old pea comb EE (my main layer rooster) that has his comb scabbed and with frost bite this year.
It really all depends on the weather and luck here, Dry cold is better than wet cold. Most people have no idea of our temps, The coldest I ever had here was about 20 years ago at 70 below. the official low was 69 below. But in all honesty anything beyond 25 below is all pretty much the same.
If someone could develop a rooster with enough brains to put his head under his wing, we might avoid frostbite.
I know I have not been part of this thread, I just felt some judgment towards those of us that have nasty frostbite. Thanks and I will sneak away quietly again..