My opinion is that it is to early to make a decision on whether or not either one of those birds is good enough to move on with. They need to be 8-9 months old before that decision is made unless there are some glaring problems.
Matt
I agree here with Matt too and even still it might be 10 to 12 months before you can tell, things change a great deal in their last stages of cockerel to cock (hormones) LOL
remember patience is key here (if one is into these for the long haul that is) if not I'd suggest some Ideal or Macmurry ones) they will get you there fast fast LOL
Jeff