Getting rid of the rooster is the right choice. It has happened once, you don't know when it will happen again. You know how fast it can happen, so you know it can happen that fast for your kids, too. They may not see it coming and end up getting injured. Who wants to have to worry about being attacked every time they go out to take care of the chores? Your kids are old enough to understand what has to be done and why. That's part of raising livestock. It is not "cruel" to kill an aggressive rooster (or any chicken for that matter) if it's done humanely. Our method of choice here is the stump-and-hatchet method. The rooster is decapitated, and it's over in an instant. There are good roosters out there. I have a brahma and he's the sweetest guy. No, he's not a "house chicken". Not even a pet. He respects me and keeps his distance. I've never had a problem with him, and I've had him for about 3 years. Your hens will not be in more danger if you get rid of the rooster. They will learn to watch the sky themselves. Sometimes a dominant hen will take over the roll of guardian. You have to do what's best for you and your family. As the parent, you need to keep your kids' best interest in mind. One thing to think about. Their reaction to it will depend entirely on yours. If you treat it like a crisis, or horrible event, so will they. If you treat it as something you've just gotta do, they'll see it the same way. They may be sad, but they'll adjust. Some kids at 12 are already helping to process chickens that they raise.
edited by staff