I have never had goat cheese like that. I swear most is not. Pinky swear even.
But I'm the kinda girl who thinks blood sausage is the best part of a Full English, LOL! I pretty much only draw the line at things that are either emotionally/culturally taboo (e.g. dog) or that I think are too high up the food chain for me to feel ok eating them (monkeys, dolphins, whales, animals that mourn their dead like hippos and elephants), or stuff that's endangered, cause that's just wrong. If there's something crazy on the menu, I'm pretty likely to order it. I've had everything you mention (except the shark) plus rattle snake, guinea pig, a variety of insects (dated an entomologist in college, his department's parties were kinda gross), buffalo, antelope, and snails.