To be honest, it would seem that his negative behavior outweighs any other considerations he gives his hens. I wouldn't encourage that he breed, as you don't want to preserve or perpetuate that type of behavior. If he can't put his hens' safety first, then he's not doing his job.
I've never tolerated roosters that were cruel to my hens. The poor girls work really hard to give me eggs and happiness, they don't deserve to be repaid by forcing them to endure a violent roo. It sounds like you've done everything you can to make him work in your flock. I'm sorry he's not working out.
I've never tolerated roosters that were cruel to my hens. The poor girls work really hard to give me eggs and happiness, they don't deserve to be repaid by forcing them to endure a violent roo. It sounds like you've done everything you can to make him work in your flock. I'm sorry he's not working out.