Not sure I agree, now having all the facts. Not at his age, if this is the ONLY couch the dogs are allowed on. This was a "perfect storm" situation. I don't think it's likely to happen again. Granny can explain this to Robert, right, Granny? Robert was on the dogs' turf. In future, if that's necessary, the dog will need to be on the floor, not where he can climb on Robert. And Robert needs to watch out that the dog doesn't climb on him so he isn't startled into swatting the dog. What do you think, Granny, is this doable? Can Robert understand that the dog did not hurt him on ourpose?then he might also be likely to guard his space, if he's dominant. I agree he needs off.