Just out of curiosity, why would you caponize the black one if you wanted to keep him because you wanted to keep his sire but didn't because of temperament? If it is bloodlines then you just kind of messed that up, and I can't see why you would keep the son of a nasty roo for sentimental reasons... Just curious, that seemed strange...
I mostly just caponized him because he was there and I needed some first time test subjects. And he turned out pretty like his dad, but the caponization is keeping him calm, and very sweet with the hens.
Oh, his dad was a handsome rooster, he was a cross of very high-quality Blue Wheaten Ameraucana and a Jersey Giant hen, he was a lot prettier than his son... pitch black with gold over the entire hackle and saddle. I hated his personality, but he was a real looker - I wanted badly to keep him, just as a
I didn't actually think daddy Winchester had bred - I run a complete mongrel flock, and he was way down in the pecking order. 90% of the offspring that come out of my big pen are fathered by my 12 lb. Orp, Benedict, so I assumed that this new batch of chicks were all his, maybe with a couple from my Dominique roo. But, whadda ya know, this little guy grows up and there's no way he's Benny's OR Nicci's offspring. No clue who the mom was, maybe my old EE hen, but anyhow, the kid turned out very handsome. Not so handsome as his dad, but all the same, he'll be my new aesthetically-pleasing freeloader. (One of them, anyways...)