Help!! Hoping our little almost 3 week Rhode Island Reds and Buff Orps are girls??

[StovallChick]

This is our first time raising chickens and we bought them from a reputable organic breeder that "sexed" them for us by checking vents and wings. We got them at 1-2 days old, now they are almost 3 weeks old. We were told they are all females but 2 of the Reds are worrying us some bc their combs are a little more prominent. But their body sizes are all the same. We have 3 reds and 3 buffs. I'm not to worried about the buffs, for now at least lol Let me know what yall think! Notice their body sizes are the same and even tail feathers. 2 of the Reds have had a black dot or line on their heads since birth, only one doesn't.

 

[StovallChick]

Here's more pics

 

[StovallChick]

Here's more pics

 

[StovallChick]

 

[StovallChick]

 

[HighStreetCoop]

Too young to tell IMO. In another 3-4 weeks it should be possible to sex them.

 

[Wyandottes7]

I think that it's too young to be sure.

 

[BantamLover21]

It is too young to tell gender for sure, though I don't see any obvious cockerel signs yet. I would post some new photos of each chick when they are at least 8 weeks old.

 

[StovallChick]

Ugh I think we've got 2 Roos

Heres one of them, this one has the biggest comb.

 

[StovallChick]

Here's the other one in the front that we think is a Roo. The red in the back I'm pretty sure is a hen, she has the smallest comb and it's still yellow.