HELP, I'm a Newbie and I Think I Have Too Many Roosters!


Apr 28, 2016
I bought 5 chicks, straight run, back in March. I thought I was lucky to have 1 rooster and 4 hens. NOT SO MUCH!
I'm posting their pictures below. My friend, who has raised chickens his whole life, told me I have 5 roos. I'm in denial but I think he's right. ugh!

Her are their pictures: I have 2 Rhode Island Reds, a Barnevelder, a Beilefelder, and an EE. All are the same age.

Probably a roo though! I just read another post and realized it's a roo.

Thanks for your help!
How old are your reds? We have 2, one we think may be a roo and the other we know is a hen. Ours are 10-12 weeks old, but we are also trying to figure out male/female chicken. 1 of ours has a big comb, but the other hasn't developed such.
My Reds were born the first week of March. They're about 20 weeks old. All of them are actually. I bet you have one of each.

I thought all roosters had large combs, I guess that's not true of Americaunas. I have SO much to learn!
I got my first chickens in April, and we have the same problem with our RIR. One of them is obviously a female in our flock, but the other has a huge comb and big waddles. We fear that we have to get rid of the chicken if it does turn out to be a roo. Only one thing you can do I guess, and that's wait until you hear it's ca-caw. :p
All roosters and the first one has gorgeous coloration

Thank you! Fluffy Jr has amazing color too. I'll find another angle of him.


New posts New threads Active threads

Top Bottom