Hens or roos?! HELP

[Painted Calls]

I think you have a bunch of mutts and not the specific mutts you were told. All the ones with muffs may lay blue or green eggs or carry the genes. Cinnamon Queen is a Red Sexlink so a cockerel wouldn't have that much red. Could be second generation, but at that point it's a mutt because it loses sexlinking. Your Silkies are hard feathered meaning they're mixes as well You also have many cockerels (at least four), I circled the obvious ones but individual pictures (of black ones in particular) would still be great in case I missed one.
View attachment 2733079
View attachment 2733078

Agreed.

I hope it was an honest mistake. Unfortunately some people aren't so honest though.

 

[Abs5648]

I'm sorry When did you get them? I wonder if someone may have pawned off some mixed breed cockerels

Just posted more pics below! I got them all when they were 1 day-1 week old

 

[Painted Calls]

All are mixes. The OE's may lay olive eggs, or they may not. I'm not sure about your two Silkie mixes. For now they look like pullets. All the rest except for the birds below, are cockerels.

 

[Abs5648]

All are mixes. The OE's may lay olive eggs, or they may not. I'm not sure about your two Silkie mixes. For now they look like pullets. All the rest except for the birds below, are cockerels.
View attachment 2733136

View attachment 2733137

That’s the same bird. So only one hen?

 

[Painted Calls]

That’s the same bird. So only one hen?

I circled 2 in that one pic. So those two plus maybe the Silkie mixes.

@Rhodebar Lover, your thoughts?

 

[Rhodebar Lover]

I circled 2 in that one pic. So those two plus maybe the Silkie mixes.

@Rhodebar Lover, your thoughts?

I agree with you!