I was picking at you, based on what some remarks on your old Silkie projects. I should insert smilies.
Guess it goes back to the different situations. Some projects require numbers. If the birds are in good shape, and pretty consistent, it does not take as many. If I will ever have the opportunity to have a respectable flock by my standards, I will have to hatch a lot. One of the hang ups that goes with a very rare and neglected breed.
My Catalanas and your Orpingtons are not even on the same playing field.
I do suspect that in a couple generations, that I will be able to settle down a bit. I am guessing that some of what I culled for last year, I will not have as much to contend with this year. I had some problems that were so bad, that I decided not to tolerate at all. These things eliminated a lot of birds. I went from in the range of 120, and I only have ten females now. Two of which are originals. So I only kept 8 pullets. I also only kept 2 cockerels. All together, I only have 14 birds on my yard now. I do not want to keep too many either.
I liken it to steering an air craft carrier. If you are heading in the right direction, you only have to make minor adjustments along the way. It takes less. If you are heading the wrong way it takes a lot to get it turned around.
There is certainly wisdom in picking a breed that is in good shape, and what some would say worth working with. Bob used to preach that to us newbies all of the time, and I get it. It just so happened to be that I wanted a project of this sort. It is also still in the realm of possibility that this effort will be a bust, and I would have wasted a lot of money, time, and effort.
All of your birds that I have seen out there look good, and do appear to be kept by people that have done well raising them up. Your birds are active and vigorous to. Many of the big birds that I have been around have been clumsy and lazy. That is not the case with your birds.